Amid Liberal sweep, biggest story of central Toronto is Annamie Paul’s loss

With the Liberal’s sweep of central Toronto ridings becoming an old story, much of the attention has focused on a certain small-party candidate who ended up a distant also-ran.

That candidate is Annamie Paul, controversial head of the Green Party, who was campaigning for the third time in Toronto Centre.

Rising from about seven per cent of the vote in 2019 to a second-place finish with 33 per cent in the 2020 by-election as a Green candidate — and now leading her party — Paul might have been expected to have a chance at unseating Liberal Marci Ien. She spent much of the election campaigning in her own riding.

But Green Party hopes were dashed in the election yesterday when Paul’s share of the vote in Toronto Centre fell to less than nine per cent. She placed fourth, behind not only Ien but also behind the NDP’s Brian Chang and Conservative Ryan Lester.

Former broadcaster Ien, who won the riding after fellow Liberal Bill Morneau resigned last year, held onto the riding in this election with a commanding 50.2 per cent of the vote.

Story continues after ad

Toronto Centre has now been in Liberal hands continuously since 1993.

Along with its sister riding of University-Rosedale, Toronto Centre is part of the Liberal sweep of Toronto ridings, which has almost become a federal election tradition.

Star Liberal cabinet minister Chrystia Freeland won University-Rosedale with nearly 47 per cent of the vote, well ahead of her New Democratic challenger Nicole Robicheau who drew just 25 per cent.

Elections Canada is still calling the results “preliminary,” as more ballots are to be counted, but Ien and Freeland have unassailable margins.

The results for the two central Toronto ridings as of 10 a.m. this morning:

Toronto Centre

  • Marci Ien, Liberal, 21,563 votes, 50.2%
  • Brian Chang, NDP, 11,118 votes, 25.9%
  • Ryan Lester, Conservative, 5,262 votes, 12.2%
  • Annamie Paul, Green Party, 3,672 votes, 8.5 %
  • Syed Jaffery, PPC, 1,082 votes, 2.5%
  • Ivan Byard, Communist, 176 votes, 0.4%
  • Peter Stubbins, Animal Protection Party, 107 votes, 0.2%


  • Chrystia Freeland, Liberal, 19,607 votes, 46.9%
  • Nicole Robicheau, NDP, 10,458 votes, 25.0 %
  • Steven Taylor, Conservative, 8,615 votes, 20.6%
  • Tim Grant, Green Party, 1,775 votes, 4.2%
  • David Kent, PPC, 1,123 votes, 2.7%
  • Drew Garvie, Communist, 229 votes, 0.5%

Freeland tweeted today that she went to Summerhill station this morning to thank voters.

Ien also thanked her supporters on social media early this morning.

As for Paul, she congratulated Ien on Twitter and urged continued aid for the riding during the pandemic.

In a speech to her supporters last night, Paul said she had congratulated Ien directly as well.

“Certainly I am disappointed — it is hard to lose, no one likes to lose,” she said in a 12-minute talk at her party headquarters. “But I am so proud of the effort, the creativity, the innovation that our team brought to this race.”